Facts, research and commentary on Australian health care

Updated 18 November 2026

Why insurers, hospitals and doctors must stay separate

by Stephen Milgate | Sep 25, 2026 | Private Health Insurance

In July 2025, the Council of Procedural Specialists put a boundary around Australia’s private system that is easy to state and hard to keep.

Stephen Milgate, CEO of COPS, said the most useful thing a federal health minister could do to preserve the balanced public/private arrangements Australians actually use was this: keep health insurance, private hospitals and medical services separate, and free of conflicts of interest.

The warning was not theoretical. Catholic Health Australia, the Australian Private Hospitals Association and the AMA had already cautioned that letting corporate funds extend ownership into hospitals and medical services — vertical integration — could open a path to US-style managed care. COPS endorsed that concern and asked the minister not to allow a corporate takeover of a private sector that Medicare already underwrites.

The ACCC also took Bupa to the Federal Court over claims it said were wrongly denied, affecting members for more than five years. The Australian Doctors Federation treated that case as evidence of what a third party can do when it sits between the treatment and the benefit the patient thought they had bought: ration by administration, then call it policy.

## Three functions, three accountabilities

The private system works, when it works, because three jobs stay in different hands.

Funds collect premiums and pay benefits. Hospitals supply beds, theatres and nursing. Doctors decide, with the patient, what should be done.

Collapse those roles and the incentives change. A fund that also owns the hospital has a view on length of stay, theatre lists and which prosthesis is on the shelf. A fund that also contracts the surgeon has a view on protocol. The patient has a view on the operation that fits this body, this comorbidity, this recovery. Those views are not automatically the same.

The doctor still carries the legal duty of care. The fund does not stand in the dock if the contracted pathway was wrong for that person. That inversion — commercial protocol, clinical liability — is the structural objection that has run through ADF, COPS and ASOS material for decades.

## What vertical integration is sold as

The commercial pitch is efficiency. If payer, facility and clinician sit in one group, incentives “align,” waste falls, and the member pays less.

That is now the argument used in the United States as insurers buy clinics and employ doctors. In 2023 the ADF republished analysis from *The Economist*: of the US$4.3 trillion spent on US healthcare in 2022, about 45 per cent went to intermediaries — insurers, pharmacy-benefit managers, distributors — sitting between patients and treatment. Those firms then bought the delivery end on the claim that one roof would lower costs.

Australia does not have that market. It does have the same logic arriving in pieces: buying groups that negotiate hospital and specialist contracts for multiple payers; no-gap and known-gap networks that steer work; product design that pays a different rebate if the patient leaves the network.

Honeysuckle Health is the current Australian case. Authorised by the ACCC in 2021 as a nib–Cigna joint venture buying group, with the largest funds excluded and a five-year term, it is now wholly owned by nib. In 2026 the parties sought a further decade of authorisation. Specialist groups argue the ownership change alters the competitive story the Commission first accepted. Whether that is a competition problem is for the ACCC. Whether it is wise for patients is a clinical-governance question: how many of the three functions now occupy the same building?

## Community rating does not sit easily with one owner

Australian private health insurance is not ordinary insurance. It is a community-rated membership scheme. Healthy members subsidise sicker ones. Premiums are not supposed to follow individual risk.

That rule is a humanitarian leftover of the old mutual funds. For-profit ownership of the whole chain pulls against it. The commercial logic is to select risk, standardise the product, and control cost at every step — hospital, device, length of stay, which doctor is “in.”

Milgate and Aniello Iannuzzi set that tension out in *InSight+* in March 2020: community rating and investor return are not natural partners. When they are forced into the same entity, the usual result is more exclusions, more tiers, and more direction of where the patient may go without a financial penalty.

COPS’s 2025 statement said the same thing in one sentence. It is in the DNA of for-profit health corporations to control the parts of the business they can control. That motive does not naturally fit community rating. When the two clash, patients wear the result.

## This is not an argument against private cover

The same organisations that oppose vertical integration have spent decades defending a mixed system.

The ADF supports strong public and private hospital sectors, each doing what it does well. It supports patient choice of doctor and the right to a second opinion. It supports the GP as the independent first assessor — and it opposes bundled payments, capitation and schemes designed to bypass that role. It supports a PHI rebate that does not fall away because the patient chose a doctor outside a fund network.

The objection is not to private insurance. It is to private insurance that begins to behave like a managed-care company: paying the bill on condition that it also writes the pathway.

Short-stay surgery and tighter rehabilitation protocols illustrate the difference. Australian surgeons have been shortening length of stay since the 1970s. When a fund then mandates the protocol and retains the savings, an innovation that began at the operating table is captured by the payer. The clinical work remains the doctor’s; the discretion does not.

## Four questions before admission

If separation is the rule, transparency is the test. A patient — and the referring GP — should be able to answer four questions before a booked admission:

1. Who is paying?

2. Who owns the hospital?

3. Who is the doctor answerable to if the right treatment is not the contracted treatment?

4. What happens to the rebate if the patient chooses a different doctor or a different hospital?

Where those answers are clear, Australia still has a mixed system with choice. Where they are buried in a network schedule, a buying-group deed or a vertically integrated group, the system has started to manage the care rather than fund it.

Dr Bruce Shepherd AM, founder of the Australian Doctors Federation, compressed the principle: the doctor must be the patient’s doctor — not the government’s doctor, nor the doctor of big business. COPS translates that into industry architecture. Keep the payer, the facility and the clinician in separate hands.

Funds can still compete on premiums, service and claims handling. Hospitals can still compete on quality and access. Doctors can still compete on skill and the trust of referring GPs. The patient can still walk from one to the other.

Once those three sit inside a single commercial interest, walking away is no longer a clinical decision. It is a contractual one. That is why the separation still matters.

---

**Sources**  

Council of Procedural Specialists, “Protecting Australia’s Balanced Public/Private Health System,” 16 July 2025.  
Australian Doctors Federation, advocacy positions and “The Australian Doctor,” 10 July 2025; “Where does the money go?,” 11 October 2023.  
Stephen Milgate and Aniello Iannuzzi, “Private health insurance: shifting sands,” *InSight+*, 9 March 2020.  
Stephen Milgate, “Australia’s move towards ‘managed care’,” *InSight+*, 16 November 2020.  
ACCC, Bupa Federal Court proceedings, 30 June 2025; Honeysuckle Health / nib authorisations AA1000542 and AA1000733.

Disclaimer: The information provided on this website is general in nature only and does not constitute personal, financial, legal or medical advice. Before acting on any information on this website, you should consider the appropriateness of the information for your own objectives, financial situation and medical needs.